Airship steam engine room - problems and conflict The Next CEO of Stack OverflowArctic Airships, Part 2 - NavigationHow to conquer challenger deep using steam engine?Realistic AirshipsCould a steam engine be built in ancient greece?Saucer-shaped airship: Is it stronger lighter and better?Creating a steampunk-esque/cybernetic “Big Iron” revolverFeasibility of electrically heated steam engineHow to correct aim in aerial airship combat?Steam engine in the 14-15th centuryGeneral airship question: advantages and disadvantages of size?
How do I secure a TV wall mount?
Can Sri Krishna be called 'a person'?
Are British MPs missing the point, with these 'Indicative Votes'?
Is it a bad idea to plug the other end of ESD strap to wall ground?
Could a dragon use its wings to swim?
Shortening a title without changing its meaning
Direct Implications Between USA and UK in Event of No-Deal Brexit
Why can't we say "I have been having a dog"?
Can this transistor (2n2222) take 6V on emitter-base? Am I reading datasheet incorrectly?
How can I replace x-axis labels with pre-determined symbols?
Would a grinding machine be a simple and workable propulsion system for an interplanetary spacecraft?
Salesforce opportunity stages
Does the Idaho Potato Commission associate potato skins with healthy eating?
What happens if you break a law in another country outside of that country?
Early programmable calculators with RS-232
How exploitable/balanced is this homebrew spell: Spell Permanency?
Is it OK to decorate a log book cover?
Free fall ellipse or parabola?
How badly should I try to prevent a user from XSSing themselves?
Could you use a laser beam as a modulated carrier wave for radio signal?
How dangerous is XSS
How to implement Comparable so it is consistent with identity-equality
How does a dynamic QR code work?
How to find if SQL server backup is encrypted with TDE without restoring the backup
Airship steam engine room - problems and conflict
The Next CEO of Stack OverflowArctic Airships, Part 2 - NavigationHow to conquer challenger deep using steam engine?Realistic AirshipsCould a steam engine be built in ancient greece?Saucer-shaped airship: Is it stronger lighter and better?Creating a steampunk-esque/cybernetic “Big Iron” revolverFeasibility of electrically heated steam engineHow to correct aim in aerial airship combat?Steam engine in the 14-15th centuryGeneral airship question: advantages and disadvantages of size?
$begingroup$
Writing a story with airships that are powered by steam engines. Big boiler, water tank, lots of coal. Enormous engine room. Propellers, masts with huge sails. There are steam-powered automatons in this world, and they've replaced some forms of manual labor in the workforce. For example there might be automatons built solely to work in the engine room shoveling coal into the boiler's firebox.
I'm working on a scene where the central airship needs to make a crucial landing at a destination important to the story. I want to introduce a huge problem in the engine room that's going to make that landing incredibly difficult to pull off. The main character, the chief engineer on the ship, will have one approach to solving this problem, but he's in conflict with another character (also an engineer) who wants to solve the problem her way.
When using a steam engine to power an airship, what is the most complicated steam-engine related problem that can happen? And what are the various ways engineers might try to solve this?
science-based technology engineering steampunk airships
New contributor
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Writing a story with airships that are powered by steam engines. Big boiler, water tank, lots of coal. Enormous engine room. Propellers, masts with huge sails. There are steam-powered automatons in this world, and they've replaced some forms of manual labor in the workforce. For example there might be automatons built solely to work in the engine room shoveling coal into the boiler's firebox.
I'm working on a scene where the central airship needs to make a crucial landing at a destination important to the story. I want to introduce a huge problem in the engine room that's going to make that landing incredibly difficult to pull off. The main character, the chief engineer on the ship, will have one approach to solving this problem, but he's in conflict with another character (also an engineer) who wants to solve the problem her way.
When using a steam engine to power an airship, what is the most complicated steam-engine related problem that can happen? And what are the various ways engineers might try to solve this?
science-based technology engineering steampunk airships
New contributor
$endgroup$
1
$begingroup$
Just as an idle curiosity, what are the masts and sails for? And, seriously, what kind of steam engine are we talking about? Simple expansion piston engine, multiple expansion piston engine, turbine? Does it have a condenser? I suppose it uses superheated steam -- superheated to what temperature and pressure? How does the transmission look like -- rods, gears, chains? Does it drive constant or variable speed propellers? It's hard to imagine a serious yet tricky problem on an unspecified "engine", other than "the baricoque became blocked, so the poppystress relief of the zuckumber failed".
$endgroup$
– AlexP
4 hours ago
$begingroup$
@ClausV, welcome to World Building. It would help to better understand the engines. Is there a component of lighter-than-air? If so, there could be a problem with the lifting-gas generator. Are these winged graft? Maybe a balance problem (fore-aft, or port-starboard) would work for the story. Perhaps it isn't strictly an engine problem, but a navigation problem and the disagreement is about certain precision guidance maneuvers? Knowing more actually constrains the problem, and encourages greater creativity.
$endgroup$
– cmm
3 hours ago
$begingroup$
These are really good questions, thanks. Maybe I don't know as much as I thought I did about steam power. Doubly difficult to then try to get into the head of an airship engineer with technical expertise. I was imagining the engine looked something like a Wilesco D-32. But that's mostly for aesthetic reasons. Steam from the boiler would generate lift, and the masts and sails could work for maneuverability, like the masts and sails on pirate ships. I could probably use some help in making some more decisions to constrain the problem.
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
@JBH thanks, noted. I have edited my post -- hope the question is a better fit now. Cheers
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
Excellent, thanks! One of the tricks to this site is remembering to focus on the world (where many stories can take place). In the long run, it provides you with a broader scope of detail that often exposes ideas you didn't know were there. I have retracted my VTC.
$endgroup$
– JBH
2 hours ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Writing a story with airships that are powered by steam engines. Big boiler, water tank, lots of coal. Enormous engine room. Propellers, masts with huge sails. There are steam-powered automatons in this world, and they've replaced some forms of manual labor in the workforce. For example there might be automatons built solely to work in the engine room shoveling coal into the boiler's firebox.
I'm working on a scene where the central airship needs to make a crucial landing at a destination important to the story. I want to introduce a huge problem in the engine room that's going to make that landing incredibly difficult to pull off. The main character, the chief engineer on the ship, will have one approach to solving this problem, but he's in conflict with another character (also an engineer) who wants to solve the problem her way.
When using a steam engine to power an airship, what is the most complicated steam-engine related problem that can happen? And what are the various ways engineers might try to solve this?
science-based technology engineering steampunk airships
New contributor
$endgroup$
Writing a story with airships that are powered by steam engines. Big boiler, water tank, lots of coal. Enormous engine room. Propellers, masts with huge sails. There are steam-powered automatons in this world, and they've replaced some forms of manual labor in the workforce. For example there might be automatons built solely to work in the engine room shoveling coal into the boiler's firebox.
I'm working on a scene where the central airship needs to make a crucial landing at a destination important to the story. I want to introduce a huge problem in the engine room that's going to make that landing incredibly difficult to pull off. The main character, the chief engineer on the ship, will have one approach to solving this problem, but he's in conflict with another character (also an engineer) who wants to solve the problem her way.
When using a steam engine to power an airship, what is the most complicated steam-engine related problem that can happen? And what are the various ways engineers might try to solve this?
science-based technology engineering steampunk airships
science-based technology engineering steampunk airships
New contributor
New contributor
edited 2 hours ago
ClausV
New contributor
asked 4 hours ago
ClausVClausV
162
162
New contributor
New contributor
1
$begingroup$
Just as an idle curiosity, what are the masts and sails for? And, seriously, what kind of steam engine are we talking about? Simple expansion piston engine, multiple expansion piston engine, turbine? Does it have a condenser? I suppose it uses superheated steam -- superheated to what temperature and pressure? How does the transmission look like -- rods, gears, chains? Does it drive constant or variable speed propellers? It's hard to imagine a serious yet tricky problem on an unspecified "engine", other than "the baricoque became blocked, so the poppystress relief of the zuckumber failed".
$endgroup$
– AlexP
4 hours ago
$begingroup$
@ClausV, welcome to World Building. It would help to better understand the engines. Is there a component of lighter-than-air? If so, there could be a problem with the lifting-gas generator. Are these winged graft? Maybe a balance problem (fore-aft, or port-starboard) would work for the story. Perhaps it isn't strictly an engine problem, but a navigation problem and the disagreement is about certain precision guidance maneuvers? Knowing more actually constrains the problem, and encourages greater creativity.
$endgroup$
– cmm
3 hours ago
$begingroup$
These are really good questions, thanks. Maybe I don't know as much as I thought I did about steam power. Doubly difficult to then try to get into the head of an airship engineer with technical expertise. I was imagining the engine looked something like a Wilesco D-32. But that's mostly for aesthetic reasons. Steam from the boiler would generate lift, and the masts and sails could work for maneuverability, like the masts and sails on pirate ships. I could probably use some help in making some more decisions to constrain the problem.
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
@JBH thanks, noted. I have edited my post -- hope the question is a better fit now. Cheers
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
Excellent, thanks! One of the tricks to this site is remembering to focus on the world (where many stories can take place). In the long run, it provides you with a broader scope of detail that often exposes ideas you didn't know were there. I have retracted my VTC.
$endgroup$
– JBH
2 hours ago
add a comment |
1
$begingroup$
Just as an idle curiosity, what are the masts and sails for? And, seriously, what kind of steam engine are we talking about? Simple expansion piston engine, multiple expansion piston engine, turbine? Does it have a condenser? I suppose it uses superheated steam -- superheated to what temperature and pressure? How does the transmission look like -- rods, gears, chains? Does it drive constant or variable speed propellers? It's hard to imagine a serious yet tricky problem on an unspecified "engine", other than "the baricoque became blocked, so the poppystress relief of the zuckumber failed".
$endgroup$
– AlexP
4 hours ago
$begingroup$
@ClausV, welcome to World Building. It would help to better understand the engines. Is there a component of lighter-than-air? If so, there could be a problem with the lifting-gas generator. Are these winged graft? Maybe a balance problem (fore-aft, or port-starboard) would work for the story. Perhaps it isn't strictly an engine problem, but a navigation problem and the disagreement is about certain precision guidance maneuvers? Knowing more actually constrains the problem, and encourages greater creativity.
$endgroup$
– cmm
3 hours ago
$begingroup$
These are really good questions, thanks. Maybe I don't know as much as I thought I did about steam power. Doubly difficult to then try to get into the head of an airship engineer with technical expertise. I was imagining the engine looked something like a Wilesco D-32. But that's mostly for aesthetic reasons. Steam from the boiler would generate lift, and the masts and sails could work for maneuverability, like the masts and sails on pirate ships. I could probably use some help in making some more decisions to constrain the problem.
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
@JBH thanks, noted. I have edited my post -- hope the question is a better fit now. Cheers
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
Excellent, thanks! One of the tricks to this site is remembering to focus on the world (where many stories can take place). In the long run, it provides you with a broader scope of detail that often exposes ideas you didn't know were there. I have retracted my VTC.
$endgroup$
– JBH
2 hours ago
1
1
$begingroup$
Just as an idle curiosity, what are the masts and sails for? And, seriously, what kind of steam engine are we talking about? Simple expansion piston engine, multiple expansion piston engine, turbine? Does it have a condenser? I suppose it uses superheated steam -- superheated to what temperature and pressure? How does the transmission look like -- rods, gears, chains? Does it drive constant or variable speed propellers? It's hard to imagine a serious yet tricky problem on an unspecified "engine", other than "the baricoque became blocked, so the poppystress relief of the zuckumber failed".
$endgroup$
– AlexP
4 hours ago
$begingroup$
Just as an idle curiosity, what are the masts and sails for? And, seriously, what kind of steam engine are we talking about? Simple expansion piston engine, multiple expansion piston engine, turbine? Does it have a condenser? I suppose it uses superheated steam -- superheated to what temperature and pressure? How does the transmission look like -- rods, gears, chains? Does it drive constant or variable speed propellers? It's hard to imagine a serious yet tricky problem on an unspecified "engine", other than "the baricoque became blocked, so the poppystress relief of the zuckumber failed".
$endgroup$
– AlexP
4 hours ago
$begingroup$
@ClausV, welcome to World Building. It would help to better understand the engines. Is there a component of lighter-than-air? If so, there could be a problem with the lifting-gas generator. Are these winged graft? Maybe a balance problem (fore-aft, or port-starboard) would work for the story. Perhaps it isn't strictly an engine problem, but a navigation problem and the disagreement is about certain precision guidance maneuvers? Knowing more actually constrains the problem, and encourages greater creativity.
$endgroup$
– cmm
3 hours ago
$begingroup$
@ClausV, welcome to World Building. It would help to better understand the engines. Is there a component of lighter-than-air? If so, there could be a problem with the lifting-gas generator. Are these winged graft? Maybe a balance problem (fore-aft, or port-starboard) would work for the story. Perhaps it isn't strictly an engine problem, but a navigation problem and the disagreement is about certain precision guidance maneuvers? Knowing more actually constrains the problem, and encourages greater creativity.
$endgroup$
– cmm
3 hours ago
$begingroup$
These are really good questions, thanks. Maybe I don't know as much as I thought I did about steam power. Doubly difficult to then try to get into the head of an airship engineer with technical expertise. I was imagining the engine looked something like a Wilesco D-32. But that's mostly for aesthetic reasons. Steam from the boiler would generate lift, and the masts and sails could work for maneuverability, like the masts and sails on pirate ships. I could probably use some help in making some more decisions to constrain the problem.
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
These are really good questions, thanks. Maybe I don't know as much as I thought I did about steam power. Doubly difficult to then try to get into the head of an airship engineer with technical expertise. I was imagining the engine looked something like a Wilesco D-32. But that's mostly for aesthetic reasons. Steam from the boiler would generate lift, and the masts and sails could work for maneuverability, like the masts and sails on pirate ships. I could probably use some help in making some more decisions to constrain the problem.
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
@JBH thanks, noted. I have edited my post -- hope the question is a better fit now. Cheers
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
@JBH thanks, noted. I have edited my post -- hope the question is a better fit now. Cheers
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
Excellent, thanks! One of the tricks to this site is remembering to focus on the world (where many stories can take place). In the long run, it provides you with a broader scope of detail that often exposes ideas you didn't know were there. I have retracted my VTC.
$endgroup$
– JBH
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
Excellent, thanks! One of the tricks to this site is remembering to focus on the world (where many stories can take place). In the long run, it provides you with a broader scope of detail that often exposes ideas you didn't know were there. I have retracted my VTC.
$endgroup$
– JBH
2 hours ago
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
Murderous Steam EVERYWHERE
Background: I worked in the Engine Room of a Nuclear Submarine... where we use a steam cycle to generate power.
One of the worst things that can possibly happen in a steam power engine room is the "Steam Line Rupture Casualty."
Basically, you are using high pressure steam to move turbine blades, so there's piping that moves the steam around. If that piping breaks - due to corrosion, over pressure, someone dropped something heavy on it, whatever - now the boilers are putting super-heated steam into the people spaces. Basically, now the whole system is attempting to cook the crew.
The classic answer is to remove the source of steam - you can vent it directly out of the boilers to overboard or you can just let steam pressure build up in the boilers, but the important thing is you have to stop the steam from entering the engine room. Otherwise everyone dies.
So maybe your crew is facing a situation where for some reason they cannot fully do the "right thing." A valve got stuck? The operator got cooked before he finished operating it? Now you've got conflict - how do you fix the system while the engine room is partially filled with murderously hot steam?
Do you put a patch over the damaged piping? Redirect steam around the broken piping (since your ship has redundancy)? Fix the stuck venting valve?
Who is risking their lives to do this? What kind of protective gear can you get them into in time? Do they need help?
The answers might not be clear, unless you're the Chief Engineer!
$endgroup$
2
$begingroup$
But the Chief Engineer's shift just ended and he/she is done for the day. (Technically- well done)
$endgroup$
– Michael Kutz
2 hours ago
1
$begingroup$
Looking at a comment in the question it seems that the idea is to use the steam for controlled lift by venting it to the gasbag, ie. the gasbag doubles as the condenser, so that is where they'd default to venting the steam? That valve getting blocked would be a serious issue since it wouldn't just prevent venting overpressure, it would also directly cause overpressure in the boiler and reduce lift. Although there would have to be a backup valve, surely. Probably unnecessary but since you have personal experience I'll just say that pressures and temps would be much lower here.
$endgroup$
– Ville Niemi
1 hour ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Let's start with some ideas.
Heat/Fuel
The boiler is running hot and it's causing the surrounding structure to start to burn!
The heat of the firebox is causing a critical component (let's say a crankshaft or linkage) to begin to warp.
Coal dust in the firebox area exploded! How do we land this beast safely when there's little of the firebox area left?
Pressure/Water
We blew a gasket! It's bad enough we're losing pressure, but we're also running out of water.
A headwind is forcing the pressure up (technically not a pressure problem, but it can be a pressure solution. Wind against the propellers increases, which translates to force applied against the pressure of the steam — resulting in more pressure. You can't just lower the pressure or you start flying backwards).
Pressure expansion has forced the boiler against the containing walls of the airship — and they're starting to give way (structural integrity problem).
Engine linkages
- Have you ever had the tires on your car aligned, only to have the mechanic show you the linkage and how the normally round hole is now an oval that won't allow the alignment to stay in place? Now, imagine that with the power of a steam engine. And every time that linkage rotates around, the situation gets worse. What will give first? The piston or the linkage? They're both taking a beating.
My favorite is the coal dust exploding
Why? Because it could be an issue of wind direction or outside air pressure that's keeping the dust from venting normally. Or a failure of the ventilation system or sabotage. Or a loss of control of the flamebox door. There are a lot of ways a story can build the threat of an imminent (and very real) disaster without having to experience the disaster right now! It depends on where your strengths as a writer lie. If you're great at writing moment-by-moment middle-of-the-disaster scenes, then one of the other problems would be better. If you're better at solve-the-puzzle-before-time-runs-out type of story, this is your baby.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Timing Issues
Most complex machines use timing belts to keep different components working together synchronously. When timing belts fail, it's usually a bad day (eg, the car engine seizes up). Something as important as an airship will probably have fail-safes in place, as any one timing belt would create a single point of failure, and it's not like you can just "pull over" (in a car), or pause the engine (in a boat) to fix it. The airship demands continuous action.
So what if, instead of something failing it gets off - but only slightly. These types of timing problems can be very tricky to detect. The larger, more complicated the system, the more difficult it may be to detect.
But it gets worse...
You mention automatons working in the engine room. What if they're all just slightly off? This could start by causing engine strain, a blown gasket here or there, and so on. The more off-sync the automatons are, the more catastrophic the problem. Ironically, this means the timing failure becomes it's own type of clock - if the timing issue is increasing by one millisecond every hour, and catastrophe occurs at ten milliseconds off, then in ten hours we're all screwed.
Solutions for timing issues are never easy, but the best way mechanics do this is usually "stop the engine, replace the belt, try again". Can't do that on an airship! Furthermore, even if one component can be stopped the idea of "stop the component, replace the belt, try again" may not work - the automatons are still out of sync! So the real question becomes "how do we get everything back in sync - and without stopping the automatons?"
Fixing the problem
Possible solutions include manually adjusting one piece at a time, forcing a failure on a component (forcing the backup to take-over), replacing an automaton with a human temporarily (assuming the human has good timing, and there are enough humans!), and so on. This helps with your central conflict, though, as you might not be able to try multiple solutions at once, so one of the two characters will have to give in.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function ()
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function ()
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix)
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
);
);
, "mathjax-editing");
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "579"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
ClausV is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f142978%2fairship-steam-engine-room-problems-and-conflict%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
$begingroup$
Murderous Steam EVERYWHERE
Background: I worked in the Engine Room of a Nuclear Submarine... where we use a steam cycle to generate power.
One of the worst things that can possibly happen in a steam power engine room is the "Steam Line Rupture Casualty."
Basically, you are using high pressure steam to move turbine blades, so there's piping that moves the steam around. If that piping breaks - due to corrosion, over pressure, someone dropped something heavy on it, whatever - now the boilers are putting super-heated steam into the people spaces. Basically, now the whole system is attempting to cook the crew.
The classic answer is to remove the source of steam - you can vent it directly out of the boilers to overboard or you can just let steam pressure build up in the boilers, but the important thing is you have to stop the steam from entering the engine room. Otherwise everyone dies.
So maybe your crew is facing a situation where for some reason they cannot fully do the "right thing." A valve got stuck? The operator got cooked before he finished operating it? Now you've got conflict - how do you fix the system while the engine room is partially filled with murderously hot steam?
Do you put a patch over the damaged piping? Redirect steam around the broken piping (since your ship has redundancy)? Fix the stuck venting valve?
Who is risking their lives to do this? What kind of protective gear can you get them into in time? Do they need help?
The answers might not be clear, unless you're the Chief Engineer!
$endgroup$
2
$begingroup$
But the Chief Engineer's shift just ended and he/she is done for the day. (Technically- well done)
$endgroup$
– Michael Kutz
2 hours ago
1
$begingroup$
Looking at a comment in the question it seems that the idea is to use the steam for controlled lift by venting it to the gasbag, ie. the gasbag doubles as the condenser, so that is where they'd default to venting the steam? That valve getting blocked would be a serious issue since it wouldn't just prevent venting overpressure, it would also directly cause overpressure in the boiler and reduce lift. Although there would have to be a backup valve, surely. Probably unnecessary but since you have personal experience I'll just say that pressures and temps would be much lower here.
$endgroup$
– Ville Niemi
1 hour ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Murderous Steam EVERYWHERE
Background: I worked in the Engine Room of a Nuclear Submarine... where we use a steam cycle to generate power.
One of the worst things that can possibly happen in a steam power engine room is the "Steam Line Rupture Casualty."
Basically, you are using high pressure steam to move turbine blades, so there's piping that moves the steam around. If that piping breaks - due to corrosion, over pressure, someone dropped something heavy on it, whatever - now the boilers are putting super-heated steam into the people spaces. Basically, now the whole system is attempting to cook the crew.
The classic answer is to remove the source of steam - you can vent it directly out of the boilers to overboard or you can just let steam pressure build up in the boilers, but the important thing is you have to stop the steam from entering the engine room. Otherwise everyone dies.
So maybe your crew is facing a situation where for some reason they cannot fully do the "right thing." A valve got stuck? The operator got cooked before he finished operating it? Now you've got conflict - how do you fix the system while the engine room is partially filled with murderously hot steam?
Do you put a patch over the damaged piping? Redirect steam around the broken piping (since your ship has redundancy)? Fix the stuck venting valve?
Who is risking their lives to do this? What kind of protective gear can you get them into in time? Do they need help?
The answers might not be clear, unless you're the Chief Engineer!
$endgroup$
2
$begingroup$
But the Chief Engineer's shift just ended and he/she is done for the day. (Technically- well done)
$endgroup$
– Michael Kutz
2 hours ago
1
$begingroup$
Looking at a comment in the question it seems that the idea is to use the steam for controlled lift by venting it to the gasbag, ie. the gasbag doubles as the condenser, so that is where they'd default to venting the steam? That valve getting blocked would be a serious issue since it wouldn't just prevent venting overpressure, it would also directly cause overpressure in the boiler and reduce lift. Although there would have to be a backup valve, surely. Probably unnecessary but since you have personal experience I'll just say that pressures and temps would be much lower here.
$endgroup$
– Ville Niemi
1 hour ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Murderous Steam EVERYWHERE
Background: I worked in the Engine Room of a Nuclear Submarine... where we use a steam cycle to generate power.
One of the worst things that can possibly happen in a steam power engine room is the "Steam Line Rupture Casualty."
Basically, you are using high pressure steam to move turbine blades, so there's piping that moves the steam around. If that piping breaks - due to corrosion, over pressure, someone dropped something heavy on it, whatever - now the boilers are putting super-heated steam into the people spaces. Basically, now the whole system is attempting to cook the crew.
The classic answer is to remove the source of steam - you can vent it directly out of the boilers to overboard or you can just let steam pressure build up in the boilers, but the important thing is you have to stop the steam from entering the engine room. Otherwise everyone dies.
So maybe your crew is facing a situation where for some reason they cannot fully do the "right thing." A valve got stuck? The operator got cooked before he finished operating it? Now you've got conflict - how do you fix the system while the engine room is partially filled with murderously hot steam?
Do you put a patch over the damaged piping? Redirect steam around the broken piping (since your ship has redundancy)? Fix the stuck venting valve?
Who is risking their lives to do this? What kind of protective gear can you get them into in time? Do they need help?
The answers might not be clear, unless you're the Chief Engineer!
$endgroup$
Murderous Steam EVERYWHERE
Background: I worked in the Engine Room of a Nuclear Submarine... where we use a steam cycle to generate power.
One of the worst things that can possibly happen in a steam power engine room is the "Steam Line Rupture Casualty."
Basically, you are using high pressure steam to move turbine blades, so there's piping that moves the steam around. If that piping breaks - due to corrosion, over pressure, someone dropped something heavy on it, whatever - now the boilers are putting super-heated steam into the people spaces. Basically, now the whole system is attempting to cook the crew.
The classic answer is to remove the source of steam - you can vent it directly out of the boilers to overboard or you can just let steam pressure build up in the boilers, but the important thing is you have to stop the steam from entering the engine room. Otherwise everyone dies.
So maybe your crew is facing a situation where for some reason they cannot fully do the "right thing." A valve got stuck? The operator got cooked before he finished operating it? Now you've got conflict - how do you fix the system while the engine room is partially filled with murderously hot steam?
Do you put a patch over the damaged piping? Redirect steam around the broken piping (since your ship has redundancy)? Fix the stuck venting valve?
Who is risking their lives to do this? What kind of protective gear can you get them into in time? Do they need help?
The answers might not be clear, unless you're the Chief Engineer!
answered 3 hours ago
codeMonkeycodeMonkey
3,411820
3,411820
2
$begingroup$
But the Chief Engineer's shift just ended and he/she is done for the day. (Technically- well done)
$endgroup$
– Michael Kutz
2 hours ago
1
$begingroup$
Looking at a comment in the question it seems that the idea is to use the steam for controlled lift by venting it to the gasbag, ie. the gasbag doubles as the condenser, so that is where they'd default to venting the steam? That valve getting blocked would be a serious issue since it wouldn't just prevent venting overpressure, it would also directly cause overpressure in the boiler and reduce lift. Although there would have to be a backup valve, surely. Probably unnecessary but since you have personal experience I'll just say that pressures and temps would be much lower here.
$endgroup$
– Ville Niemi
1 hour ago
add a comment |
2
$begingroup$
But the Chief Engineer's shift just ended and he/she is done for the day. (Technically- well done)
$endgroup$
– Michael Kutz
2 hours ago
1
$begingroup$
Looking at a comment in the question it seems that the idea is to use the steam for controlled lift by venting it to the gasbag, ie. the gasbag doubles as the condenser, so that is where they'd default to venting the steam? That valve getting blocked would be a serious issue since it wouldn't just prevent venting overpressure, it would also directly cause overpressure in the boiler and reduce lift. Although there would have to be a backup valve, surely. Probably unnecessary but since you have personal experience I'll just say that pressures and temps would be much lower here.
$endgroup$
– Ville Niemi
1 hour ago
2
2
$begingroup$
But the Chief Engineer's shift just ended and he/she is done for the day. (Technically- well done)
$endgroup$
– Michael Kutz
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
But the Chief Engineer's shift just ended and he/she is done for the day. (Technically- well done)
$endgroup$
– Michael Kutz
2 hours ago
1
1
$begingroup$
Looking at a comment in the question it seems that the idea is to use the steam for controlled lift by venting it to the gasbag, ie. the gasbag doubles as the condenser, so that is where they'd default to venting the steam? That valve getting blocked would be a serious issue since it wouldn't just prevent venting overpressure, it would also directly cause overpressure in the boiler and reduce lift. Although there would have to be a backup valve, surely. Probably unnecessary but since you have personal experience I'll just say that pressures and temps would be much lower here.
$endgroup$
– Ville Niemi
1 hour ago
$begingroup$
Looking at a comment in the question it seems that the idea is to use the steam for controlled lift by venting it to the gasbag, ie. the gasbag doubles as the condenser, so that is where they'd default to venting the steam? That valve getting blocked would be a serious issue since it wouldn't just prevent venting overpressure, it would also directly cause overpressure in the boiler and reduce lift. Although there would have to be a backup valve, surely. Probably unnecessary but since you have personal experience I'll just say that pressures and temps would be much lower here.
$endgroup$
– Ville Niemi
1 hour ago
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Let's start with some ideas.
Heat/Fuel
The boiler is running hot and it's causing the surrounding structure to start to burn!
The heat of the firebox is causing a critical component (let's say a crankshaft or linkage) to begin to warp.
Coal dust in the firebox area exploded! How do we land this beast safely when there's little of the firebox area left?
Pressure/Water
We blew a gasket! It's bad enough we're losing pressure, but we're also running out of water.
A headwind is forcing the pressure up (technically not a pressure problem, but it can be a pressure solution. Wind against the propellers increases, which translates to force applied against the pressure of the steam — resulting in more pressure. You can't just lower the pressure or you start flying backwards).
Pressure expansion has forced the boiler against the containing walls of the airship — and they're starting to give way (structural integrity problem).
Engine linkages
- Have you ever had the tires on your car aligned, only to have the mechanic show you the linkage and how the normally round hole is now an oval that won't allow the alignment to stay in place? Now, imagine that with the power of a steam engine. And every time that linkage rotates around, the situation gets worse. What will give first? The piston or the linkage? They're both taking a beating.
My favorite is the coal dust exploding
Why? Because it could be an issue of wind direction or outside air pressure that's keeping the dust from venting normally. Or a failure of the ventilation system or sabotage. Or a loss of control of the flamebox door. There are a lot of ways a story can build the threat of an imminent (and very real) disaster without having to experience the disaster right now! It depends on where your strengths as a writer lie. If you're great at writing moment-by-moment middle-of-the-disaster scenes, then one of the other problems would be better. If you're better at solve-the-puzzle-before-time-runs-out type of story, this is your baby.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Let's start with some ideas.
Heat/Fuel
The boiler is running hot and it's causing the surrounding structure to start to burn!
The heat of the firebox is causing a critical component (let's say a crankshaft or linkage) to begin to warp.
Coal dust in the firebox area exploded! How do we land this beast safely when there's little of the firebox area left?
Pressure/Water
We blew a gasket! It's bad enough we're losing pressure, but we're also running out of water.
A headwind is forcing the pressure up (technically not a pressure problem, but it can be a pressure solution. Wind against the propellers increases, which translates to force applied against the pressure of the steam — resulting in more pressure. You can't just lower the pressure or you start flying backwards).
Pressure expansion has forced the boiler against the containing walls of the airship — and they're starting to give way (structural integrity problem).
Engine linkages
- Have you ever had the tires on your car aligned, only to have the mechanic show you the linkage and how the normally round hole is now an oval that won't allow the alignment to stay in place? Now, imagine that with the power of a steam engine. And every time that linkage rotates around, the situation gets worse. What will give first? The piston or the linkage? They're both taking a beating.
My favorite is the coal dust exploding
Why? Because it could be an issue of wind direction or outside air pressure that's keeping the dust from venting normally. Or a failure of the ventilation system or sabotage. Or a loss of control of the flamebox door. There are a lot of ways a story can build the threat of an imminent (and very real) disaster without having to experience the disaster right now! It depends on where your strengths as a writer lie. If you're great at writing moment-by-moment middle-of-the-disaster scenes, then one of the other problems would be better. If you're better at solve-the-puzzle-before-time-runs-out type of story, this is your baby.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Let's start with some ideas.
Heat/Fuel
The boiler is running hot and it's causing the surrounding structure to start to burn!
The heat of the firebox is causing a critical component (let's say a crankshaft or linkage) to begin to warp.
Coal dust in the firebox area exploded! How do we land this beast safely when there's little of the firebox area left?
Pressure/Water
We blew a gasket! It's bad enough we're losing pressure, but we're also running out of water.
A headwind is forcing the pressure up (technically not a pressure problem, but it can be a pressure solution. Wind against the propellers increases, which translates to force applied against the pressure of the steam — resulting in more pressure. You can't just lower the pressure or you start flying backwards).
Pressure expansion has forced the boiler against the containing walls of the airship — and they're starting to give way (structural integrity problem).
Engine linkages
- Have you ever had the tires on your car aligned, only to have the mechanic show you the linkage and how the normally round hole is now an oval that won't allow the alignment to stay in place? Now, imagine that with the power of a steam engine. And every time that linkage rotates around, the situation gets worse. What will give first? The piston or the linkage? They're both taking a beating.
My favorite is the coal dust exploding
Why? Because it could be an issue of wind direction or outside air pressure that's keeping the dust from venting normally. Or a failure of the ventilation system or sabotage. Or a loss of control of the flamebox door. There are a lot of ways a story can build the threat of an imminent (and very real) disaster without having to experience the disaster right now! It depends on where your strengths as a writer lie. If you're great at writing moment-by-moment middle-of-the-disaster scenes, then one of the other problems would be better. If you're better at solve-the-puzzle-before-time-runs-out type of story, this is your baby.
$endgroup$
Let's start with some ideas.
Heat/Fuel
The boiler is running hot and it's causing the surrounding structure to start to burn!
The heat of the firebox is causing a critical component (let's say a crankshaft or linkage) to begin to warp.
Coal dust in the firebox area exploded! How do we land this beast safely when there's little of the firebox area left?
Pressure/Water
We blew a gasket! It's bad enough we're losing pressure, but we're also running out of water.
A headwind is forcing the pressure up (technically not a pressure problem, but it can be a pressure solution. Wind against the propellers increases, which translates to force applied against the pressure of the steam — resulting in more pressure. You can't just lower the pressure or you start flying backwards).
Pressure expansion has forced the boiler against the containing walls of the airship — and they're starting to give way (structural integrity problem).
Engine linkages
- Have you ever had the tires on your car aligned, only to have the mechanic show you the linkage and how the normally round hole is now an oval that won't allow the alignment to stay in place? Now, imagine that with the power of a steam engine. And every time that linkage rotates around, the situation gets worse. What will give first? The piston or the linkage? They're both taking a beating.
My favorite is the coal dust exploding
Why? Because it could be an issue of wind direction or outside air pressure that's keeping the dust from venting normally. Or a failure of the ventilation system or sabotage. Or a loss of control of the flamebox door. There are a lot of ways a story can build the threat of an imminent (and very real) disaster without having to experience the disaster right now! It depends on where your strengths as a writer lie. If you're great at writing moment-by-moment middle-of-the-disaster scenes, then one of the other problems would be better. If you're better at solve-the-puzzle-before-time-runs-out type of story, this is your baby.
answered 2 hours ago
JBHJBH
47.5k699222
47.5k699222
add a comment |
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Timing Issues
Most complex machines use timing belts to keep different components working together synchronously. When timing belts fail, it's usually a bad day (eg, the car engine seizes up). Something as important as an airship will probably have fail-safes in place, as any one timing belt would create a single point of failure, and it's not like you can just "pull over" (in a car), or pause the engine (in a boat) to fix it. The airship demands continuous action.
So what if, instead of something failing it gets off - but only slightly. These types of timing problems can be very tricky to detect. The larger, more complicated the system, the more difficult it may be to detect.
But it gets worse...
You mention automatons working in the engine room. What if they're all just slightly off? This could start by causing engine strain, a blown gasket here or there, and so on. The more off-sync the automatons are, the more catastrophic the problem. Ironically, this means the timing failure becomes it's own type of clock - if the timing issue is increasing by one millisecond every hour, and catastrophe occurs at ten milliseconds off, then in ten hours we're all screwed.
Solutions for timing issues are never easy, but the best way mechanics do this is usually "stop the engine, replace the belt, try again". Can't do that on an airship! Furthermore, even if one component can be stopped the idea of "stop the component, replace the belt, try again" may not work - the automatons are still out of sync! So the real question becomes "how do we get everything back in sync - and without stopping the automatons?"
Fixing the problem
Possible solutions include manually adjusting one piece at a time, forcing a failure on a component (forcing the backup to take-over), replacing an automaton with a human temporarily (assuming the human has good timing, and there are enough humans!), and so on. This helps with your central conflict, though, as you might not be able to try multiple solutions at once, so one of the two characters will have to give in.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Timing Issues
Most complex machines use timing belts to keep different components working together synchronously. When timing belts fail, it's usually a bad day (eg, the car engine seizes up). Something as important as an airship will probably have fail-safes in place, as any one timing belt would create a single point of failure, and it's not like you can just "pull over" (in a car), or pause the engine (in a boat) to fix it. The airship demands continuous action.
So what if, instead of something failing it gets off - but only slightly. These types of timing problems can be very tricky to detect. The larger, more complicated the system, the more difficult it may be to detect.
But it gets worse...
You mention automatons working in the engine room. What if they're all just slightly off? This could start by causing engine strain, a blown gasket here or there, and so on. The more off-sync the automatons are, the more catastrophic the problem. Ironically, this means the timing failure becomes it's own type of clock - if the timing issue is increasing by one millisecond every hour, and catastrophe occurs at ten milliseconds off, then in ten hours we're all screwed.
Solutions for timing issues are never easy, but the best way mechanics do this is usually "stop the engine, replace the belt, try again". Can't do that on an airship! Furthermore, even if one component can be stopped the idea of "stop the component, replace the belt, try again" may not work - the automatons are still out of sync! So the real question becomes "how do we get everything back in sync - and without stopping the automatons?"
Fixing the problem
Possible solutions include manually adjusting one piece at a time, forcing a failure on a component (forcing the backup to take-over), replacing an automaton with a human temporarily (assuming the human has good timing, and there are enough humans!), and so on. This helps with your central conflict, though, as you might not be able to try multiple solutions at once, so one of the two characters will have to give in.
$endgroup$
add a comment |
$begingroup$
Timing Issues
Most complex machines use timing belts to keep different components working together synchronously. When timing belts fail, it's usually a bad day (eg, the car engine seizes up). Something as important as an airship will probably have fail-safes in place, as any one timing belt would create a single point of failure, and it's not like you can just "pull over" (in a car), or pause the engine (in a boat) to fix it. The airship demands continuous action.
So what if, instead of something failing it gets off - but only slightly. These types of timing problems can be very tricky to detect. The larger, more complicated the system, the more difficult it may be to detect.
But it gets worse...
You mention automatons working in the engine room. What if they're all just slightly off? This could start by causing engine strain, a blown gasket here or there, and so on. The more off-sync the automatons are, the more catastrophic the problem. Ironically, this means the timing failure becomes it's own type of clock - if the timing issue is increasing by one millisecond every hour, and catastrophe occurs at ten milliseconds off, then in ten hours we're all screwed.
Solutions for timing issues are never easy, but the best way mechanics do this is usually "stop the engine, replace the belt, try again". Can't do that on an airship! Furthermore, even if one component can be stopped the idea of "stop the component, replace the belt, try again" may not work - the automatons are still out of sync! So the real question becomes "how do we get everything back in sync - and without stopping the automatons?"
Fixing the problem
Possible solutions include manually adjusting one piece at a time, forcing a failure on a component (forcing the backup to take-over), replacing an automaton with a human temporarily (assuming the human has good timing, and there are enough humans!), and so on. This helps with your central conflict, though, as you might not be able to try multiple solutions at once, so one of the two characters will have to give in.
$endgroup$
Timing Issues
Most complex machines use timing belts to keep different components working together synchronously. When timing belts fail, it's usually a bad day (eg, the car engine seizes up). Something as important as an airship will probably have fail-safes in place, as any one timing belt would create a single point of failure, and it's not like you can just "pull over" (in a car), or pause the engine (in a boat) to fix it. The airship demands continuous action.
So what if, instead of something failing it gets off - but only slightly. These types of timing problems can be very tricky to detect. The larger, more complicated the system, the more difficult it may be to detect.
But it gets worse...
You mention automatons working in the engine room. What if they're all just slightly off? This could start by causing engine strain, a blown gasket here or there, and so on. The more off-sync the automatons are, the more catastrophic the problem. Ironically, this means the timing failure becomes it's own type of clock - if the timing issue is increasing by one millisecond every hour, and catastrophe occurs at ten milliseconds off, then in ten hours we're all screwed.
Solutions for timing issues are never easy, but the best way mechanics do this is usually "stop the engine, replace the belt, try again". Can't do that on an airship! Furthermore, even if one component can be stopped the idea of "stop the component, replace the belt, try again" may not work - the automatons are still out of sync! So the real question becomes "how do we get everything back in sync - and without stopping the automatons?"
Fixing the problem
Possible solutions include manually adjusting one piece at a time, forcing a failure on a component (forcing the backup to take-over), replacing an automaton with a human temporarily (assuming the human has good timing, and there are enough humans!), and so on. This helps with your central conflict, though, as you might not be able to try multiple solutions at once, so one of the two characters will have to give in.
answered 51 mins ago
cegfaultcegfault
1,367512
1,367512
add a comment |
add a comment |
ClausV is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
ClausV is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
ClausV is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
ClausV is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Thanks for contributing an answer to Worldbuilding Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f142978%2fairship-steam-engine-room-problems-and-conflict%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
1
$begingroup$
Just as an idle curiosity, what are the masts and sails for? And, seriously, what kind of steam engine are we talking about? Simple expansion piston engine, multiple expansion piston engine, turbine? Does it have a condenser? I suppose it uses superheated steam -- superheated to what temperature and pressure? How does the transmission look like -- rods, gears, chains? Does it drive constant or variable speed propellers? It's hard to imagine a serious yet tricky problem on an unspecified "engine", other than "the baricoque became blocked, so the poppystress relief of the zuckumber failed".
$endgroup$
– AlexP
4 hours ago
$begingroup$
@ClausV, welcome to World Building. It would help to better understand the engines. Is there a component of lighter-than-air? If so, there could be a problem with the lifting-gas generator. Are these winged graft? Maybe a balance problem (fore-aft, or port-starboard) would work for the story. Perhaps it isn't strictly an engine problem, but a navigation problem and the disagreement is about certain precision guidance maneuvers? Knowing more actually constrains the problem, and encourages greater creativity.
$endgroup$
– cmm
3 hours ago
$begingroup$
These are really good questions, thanks. Maybe I don't know as much as I thought I did about steam power. Doubly difficult to then try to get into the head of an airship engineer with technical expertise. I was imagining the engine looked something like a Wilesco D-32. But that's mostly for aesthetic reasons. Steam from the boiler would generate lift, and the masts and sails could work for maneuverability, like the masts and sails on pirate ships. I could probably use some help in making some more decisions to constrain the problem.
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
@JBH thanks, noted. I have edited my post -- hope the question is a better fit now. Cheers
$endgroup$
– ClausV
2 hours ago
$begingroup$
Excellent, thanks! One of the tricks to this site is remembering to focus on the world (where many stories can take place). In the long run, it provides you with a broader scope of detail that often exposes ideas you didn't know were there. I have retracted my VTC.
$endgroup$
– JBH
2 hours ago